Gildas; and what was his problem with Arthur?
'De Excidio et Conquestu Britanniae', meaning ‘On the Ruin and Conquest of Britain’ was written in about AD 540 by the monk St Gildas, and is a, unique, near contemporary history of Britain in the fifth and sixth centuries. Gildas is primarily concerned with detailing, and fiercely lamenting, the failures, as he sees them, of the British Kings that led to the eventual dominance of the Anglo-Saxons. Notably, he attributes the failures of the British (Celtic) Kings to their sinfulness and lack of true Christian virtue. Although he makes no specific mention of Arthur he does talk of a war leader, the Romano-British Ambrosius, who helped defeat the Saxons at the Battle of Badon. Other, later, writers often take this leader as being Arthur. Gildas is important as a writer because, even though we have to be careful when accepting what he says at face value, he is the closest to a contemporary writer we have when it comes to the ‘Dark Ages’ and the ‘Age of Arthur’. Despite being Scottish by birth, although this is disputed, and ‘retiring’ to Brittany following his monastic time in Wales, Gildas is the Patron Saint of Welsh historians, as well as an important Catholic Saint in France, with his saint day being the 29th of January. His remains, or at least part of them, are still held as religious relics at the Abbey of Saint Gildas de Rhuys in Brittany which he founded.
It is the lack of any mention of Arthur by Gildas that is often cited as 'a lack of evidence' that Arthur is a genuine historical character. However, there may be a reason why Gildas doesn't give Arthur any credit, or even a mention. Standing outside the half-timbered copy of the old Exmewe Hall (now a bank building, although at the time of writing it was under threat of closure) in St Peter’s Square in the centre of Ruthin (Ruthin, Denbighshire - town centre. LL15 1AA) is a large, weathered stone block mounted on a concrete plinth. The plaque alongside the stone reads ‘On this stone the legendary King Arthur is said to have beheaded Huail, brother of Gildas the historian, his rival in love and war’. Although the beheading story is an old local tradition the stone is more likely to have been a preaching stone or even just a marketplace marker.

There are a variety of local stories about what what happened between Arthur and Huail. One has it that Huail had, at one time fought Arthur and wounded him, leaving him with a limp. Years later, at a dance Huail recognised the disguised Arthur, some say he was even disguised as a lady, by his limp and joked about it. In a fury, he does seem to have had something of a temper, Arthur had his knights seize Huail and beheaded him on the stone in the square. Not surprisingly it would seem that Gildas, in return, simply, wrote Arthur out of history. The whole incident was, however, later recorded by Elis Gruffydd (1490-1552) the famous chronicler of Welsh stories in his 'Chronicle of the Six Ages of the World' (currently held in the National Library of Wales in Aberystwyth).
So is that the reason why Arthur doesn't appear in the 'De Excidio et Conquestu Britanniae'? As always, we'll never really know!


Comments