top of page

Who was King Arthur (and what's in a name)?

Nov 8
8 min read

(Contributions are more than welcome for this ongoing, and incomplete, article which in all likelihood, will continue to grow and grow. But, please, not too wordy!)


Before getting into the debate about who King Arthur actually was, it is worth taking a moment to consider that no one knows ‘for a fact’ what the true story of King Arthur is; there simply isn’t the evidence. (And, no, I don't intend to say who I think Arthur might have been; assuming that is that he existed at all.) Whole shelf loads of writers claim to have done extensive research and give their own conclusion on who the real historical King Arthur is. This usually means they have compared a variety of documents and have then chosen a ‘best fit’ to come to a conclusion. Some of these writers have made quite a nice living by selling book after book explaining how they have discovered the ‘true’ story. Given that modern historians tend to rely on the early writers, chronicles and documents which fail to agree on dates, locations, and even names we can never absolutely know ‘the facts’ for sure.  One writer* known for a series of Arthurian books, for example, claims to have found evidence for the true identity of Arthur in a book written in the 11th century and confirmed by material in a book written in the 18th century; so four/five hundred and 13 hundred years respectively 'after the event'. Another well known writer claimed to have discovered the 'true Arthur' by looking at anagrams of the names. It might just be worth ignoring anyone whose Facebook posts include the words ‘my research shows …’ or books which include the words ‘… the true story’ in the title.


(* I have deliberately not named in authors in this article, I don't want to get any 'he said/she said' arguments. Writers are also extraordinarily quick to point out how other writers have got it wrong, which I've tried to avoid, albeit not always successfully; sometimes the academic in me just gets carried away!)


However, given all the stories that have emerged over the centuries we can give the idea of an ‘Arthurian-like’ figure, some level of historical credibility, even if we can’t ever be conclusive about it. Does this mean that there actually was an 'Arthur' or is it more likely that the name Arthur simply became associated with successful Celtic leaders because of the stories? One of the most significant arguments against Arthur as a genuine historical figure is that he, quite simply, doesn't appear in any of the early histories in any great detail. An often heard theory now is that although Arthur himself didn't exist there were a number of genuine historical figures, usually but not always involved in fighting Anglo-Saxon invaders, who inspired stories of a great warleader. This warleader in time somehow gained the name of Arthur and, thereafter, all victories became attributed to him. Some writers dismiss the lack of Arthur's name from the earliest writing by claiming that at the time he would have been known by one of the many other names which have been put forward for his identity. Alternatively mistakes in translation the wrong dates or attribution of names are often cited. It does sometimes seem as if the whole 'was Arthur a real person' debate becomes a giant, and confusing, 'chicken and egg' situation.

               

One of the most popular ideas is that Arthur was a Roman trained leader, possibly named Artorius, of a cavalry unit made up of local, native, troops patrolling Hadrian’s wall against raids by the Picts. His father was a high-born Briton, of ‘Welsh’ descent who has married the daughter of a senior Roman in order to help cement the Romano-British pact. Arthur has been bought up as a Christian, following the ‘official’ religion of the Roman Empire, and speaks both Latin and Celtic. When the Romans leave Britain he remains behind, as do many of the Romano-British and he becomes a Celtic tribal leader in his own right. However, his role remains predominately that of a war leader of cavalry-based troops. Is it likely that Arthur was in the Roman military?



Arthur being portrayed as a native warleader of cavalry based troops is not a new idea. This is the cover of 'Arthur and the Britons', based on the popular TV series, starring Oliver Tobias as Arthur, which ran from 1972 to 1973. Although it might have been rather more historically accurate than the 'knights in shining armour' version the characters' appearance in the TV series was also heavily influenced by the look of rock stars at the time. (Oliver Tobias would go on to achieve international fame in a very different sort of role, as the lead character in the1978 film 'The Stud', co-starring with Joan Collins).


We do know that the Roman's placed great emphasis on recruiting both military and civilian personnel into their ranks. These recruits would often become highly 'Romanised', would take Latin names and live in a style suited to Roman citizens. Not only were troops and civilian administrators recruited locally they were also deployed across the empire. At Rough Castle on the Antonine Wall, for example, the Centurion in charge was recorded as one Flavius Bretto, who was of either Briton or Gaul descent, whilst the troops under his command were Nervians who came from what is now Belgium. The cavalry charged with putting down a revolt in the north of England were Sarmatians, originally from as far away as Iran whilst troops based in the English Lake District were from Croatia! Most famously, at least for the Welsh, there was the army commander Magnus Maximus who was Spanish/Portuguese by birth. He married a British woman, Elen/Helen, declared himself Emperor and at the head of an army, including many Britons, conquered Rome itself. The Pillar of  Eliseg, near Llangollen, describes the Powys Royal Family as being descended from Magnus and Helen.


So, yes, it is not un reasonable to think of Arthur as being a member of the Roman military. But - was he named Artorius? Unfortunately it now seems that the main justification for claiming that Arthur was the Roman Artorius comes down to a very simple reason; the name Arthur could, it is claimed, be derived from the Latin Artorius or even that Artorius is itself a Celtic derived name. Although there was a Roman military commander called Lucius Artorius Castus who served in Britain during the 2nd Century this is at least three centuries before the time of Arthur in the late 5th Century. Is it possible that a Roman's military reputation lasted that long and inspired one of Britain's most enduring stories; it seems unlikely. Perhaps the reason why this connection is still so prevalent is that it has become popularised most notably through the 2004 film 'King Arthur' staring Clive Owen as Arthur.


However, Artorius isn't the only Romano-British military leader who has been claimed to have been Arthur. One of the most confusing of all the connections belongs to a person named Ambrosius Aurelianus. Geoffrey of Monmouth has Ambrosius as the alternative name of the young Merlin. Ambrosius can be possibly be read as the Latin version of Emrys which is, of course, the name often used in Wales for Merlin. Significantly Geoffrey, who is now renowned for simply creating tales to suit his narrative also uses the name Myrddin for Merlin and would appear to have mixed up a couple of characters from old history and Welsh myths to form his version of Merlin.


However, this doesn't seem to be the Ambrosius which other writers, most notably Gildas, identify as a Roman-British general who has survived the Saxon invasion and is, possibly, by implication even Arthur himself. We do know that Gildas took some trouble to make Ambrosius not only a Christian leader but also one with a Roman background, possibly to demonstrate his right to leadership.


To confuse things further he is also frequently recorded as the brother of Uther Pendragon which would make him Arthur’s uncle and a significant leader of the Celtic/Briton people. It is this version of Ambrosius who first allies with, and then opposes Vortigern in his leadership against the Anglo-Saxon invaders, but then, thanks to confusion caused by Geoffrey's writing seems to evolve and become Merlin. Overall, outside of fictional retelling, it is difficult to relate Ambrosius to Arthur.


Another frequently heard suggestion is Riothamus, again this is thought to be a title, meaning 'supreme king' rather than individual name. As with so many of the candidates to be Arthur the case for Riothamus revolves a genuine person with that name who was active at the right place and time. A popular way to identify Arthur is, as already seen with Artorius above, is to delve more deeply into the origins of the name itself, there are certainly no shortage of candidates here. One suggested possibility is that the name Arthur has evolved from Arth Fawr, the Welsh for 'great bear' which evolved to become Arthwyr. This name, being a leader's title rather than an individual's name has, therefore, become synonymous with any victorious Celtic warleader. At least one writer lists a number of Celtic tribal leaders with this, or very similar, titles. Variations on the Arth Fawr theme include Arcturus, supposedly, in turn, derived from Artorix, meaning Bear King. More commonly however, Arthur was equated with the boar, as in Merlin's often quoted prophecy 'The Boar of Cornwall shall bring relief from these invaders' rather than the bear.


Arthmael was a soldier and leader who was active in Brittany in the 6th century and certainly had an impact on the Breton Arthurian stories. Originally a Welsh monk who migrated to Brittany Arthmael would in due course become Saint Armel, a favourite devotional figure of King Henry VII. Interestingly Saint Armel, in addition to living at around the same time as the Arthurian stories is renowned for his martial abilities; statues of him usually depict him in armour and defeating a dragon (the Dragon of La Roche-Bernard) in a similar way to Arthur defeating various monsters..


Closer to home and another popular option amongst the various namesakes is also Artrwys a 'king' of the Silures tribe from South Wales. He was known to be active in his resistance against the Anglo-Saxons in the areas immediately adjacent to the borders of South Wales which obviously fits in neatly with the Arthurian stories. However, a northern tribal leader has also been identified as Arthur; Owain Ddantgwyn. The evidence for this being Arthur is, like so many others, largely circumstantial.


Surprisingly to many, one of the strongest claims to be an inspiration for the character of King Arthur comes from Scotland, a Prince of the Dal Raita kingdom, Artuir mac Áedáin.



The remains of Rough Castle, a Roman fort on the Antonine Wall near Falkirk in Scotland. Local legend has it that following the Roman withdrawal the fort became the home of Artuir mac Áedáin.

 

The nearby village of Camelon, now part of the suburbs of Falkirk, has, in its time, been a Pictish town and an important Roman port. It can’t be disputed that Cemelon sounds a lot like Camelot, or even Camlann, and Artuir sounds a lot like Arthur. In fact, it is possible that Artuir is derived from the Brythonic name Arthur and that he may even have had a Welsh Grandmother. Even more intriguing, Artuir mac Áedáin was never actually a king but rather a Prince of the Dal Raita kingdom on the Western coast of Scotland and, significantly, a successful military leader who fought against both the Anglo-Saxons and the Picts. It is thought that he died in battle sometime around AD 580, so in exactly the same period in which many of the Arthurian myths are based. He even, allegedly, had a sister called Morgan, again similar to the stories of Arthur and may well have known a character called Myrddin Wyllt, a well-known mystic who lived at the same time. As with all stories regarding Arthur, much of what we know about Artuir mac Áedáin is also conjecture or based on oral history and transferred to writing centuries afterwards.  However, it is just possible, as many Scots claim, that he was the inspiration for many of the Arthurian stories themselves.




Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Link
  • Link

Recent articles

Seeking Arthur logo.png

Join our mailing list

bottom of page