Which Arthur are we talking about & the importance of myth.

One of the difficulties when talking about Arthur is, quite simply, which Arthur are we talking about? In many ways there are ‘Three Arthurs’, the historical, the mythical and the legendary, none of which we have any real facts for, and all figures claimed by various different people as ‘their’ Arthur.
The historical, for want of a better word, is the Arthur who led the Celts in their resistance against the Saxons, the leader, possibly, of a Roman trained cavalry force. We know that there may well have been a Briton warleader or king who united the Celts against the incoming Saxons. Arthur may have been this leader, or more likely, the name has been connected to a number of leaders over the whole period of the Saxon incursions. Certainly in Wales it is this Arthur that people identify with, however, the historical Arthur is generally (just) starting to overtake the legendary Arthur (below) as the dominant figure of interest.
The mythical, again for want of a better word, is that of the mythical histories and stories, mostly Welsh but some Cornish, Breton and Scottish, in which Merlin/Emrys and Arthur are magical beings, with Arthur often appearing as a giant (or at least 'giant like') who are central to the founding stories of the Celtic nations. However, myths such as these often have their origin in some historical event, usually lost in the mists of time, such as those tales associated with the historical Arthur.
Finally, we have the legendary, romantic, King Arthur of the Round Table, the search for the Grail and leader of the ‘knights in shining armour’ as portrayed by Sir Thomas Malory, Tennyson, and many others. It is undeniable that what we now refer to as the legendary King Arthur could also, more accurately, be known as the fictional King Arthur, but is it a fiction based on facts and history? The earliest writers all claimed to have based their version of Arthur on even earlier history. Unfortunately, not only were these writers, Geoffrey of Monmouth, Chrétien de Troyes and Wace preeminent amongst them, placing their work in the context of the time they lived in (hence 'knights in shining armour') but they were also prone to embellish their work in order to make it popular.
Whilst the three Arthurs are obviously different characters, it is fair to say that the stories of the historical and mythical Arthurs are closely intertwined and together they have influenced the stories of the legendary Arthur. Would we even have a legendary Arthur if it wasn’t for the influence of earlier myths, and possibly history?
Increasingly, we are realising that much of what we have tended to regard as myths and legends may have their roots in distant history. Often this is history that has come down to us from its original oral traditions and has been altered, not just over time but to suit the narrative of the storyteller. We know for example that stories told to frighten children into good behaviour may talk about evil faeries but often had origins in real historical banditry. Likewise, tales of the ‘little people’ may reflect folk memory of the original inhabitants of remote regions before they were ‘civilised’. Early Christian preachers converted pagan rites into either horror stories or adapted them for their own use and, likewise, stories of military victories became interwoven with stories of divine intervention. Natural weather and environmental phenomena, often only dimly remembered from a distant past, became stories of giants and monsters throwing rocks and spilling lakes; the list goes on.
During archaeological excavations of Cadbury Castle in the sixties a good, if rather unpleasant, example of how history might influence myth was the discovery of the remains of the skeleton of a young male. It was evident that he had been buried in a strange head down position beneath the walls. This was almost certainly a human sacrifice carried out in the Iron Age period in order to ‘strengthen’ the defensive ramparts. Examples of such a ritual could easily have influenced the myth of how a young Merlin was once bought to Dinas Emrys as an intended sacrifice to stop the walls collapsing.
Significantly, myth can play a significant role in building a nation’s identity. The Tudors knew this when they claimed descent from Arthur. It wasn’t just a romantic fancy; they wanted to show that the British crown had as much grandeur and history to it as the French Crown with which they were in constant competition. As Jan Morris (1926-2020) one of the most important of all Welsh journalists and writers, said when being interviewed about her Welsh identity;
“Myths, she said, were facts, just as history was facts. Never underrate the role of
myths in the nation’s identity. They could be among its most potent ‘facts’.”
Wales, of course, still uses the Red Dragon, ‘Y Ddraig Goch’ as its national symbol and England, in turn, clings to St George slaying the dragon as a rallying symbol. Both probably (never say never!) mythical but both, equally, important as national symbols. But, anyway, as it is often said, ‘don’t let the truth get in the way of a good story’, if we dig too deeply into every myth and legend, we could well end up taking all the romance out of storytelling. So …


Comments